Books Review January 2011

Room, by Emma Donahue

“PEOPLE are locked up in all sorts of ways,” Ma tells the unremitting prime time journalist. And metaphorically Ma is right but not everybody has been locked up, under duress, in a room for seven years.

Right off the bat, through the eyes and voice of a five-year-old boy named Jack, we feel something ominous. Everything about his described world seems contained and limited. We soon realize that Ma and Jack are confined to a room and have been since the day Jack was born. Unsettlingly, he has never known anything else. What happened to Ma is every parent’s most crippling fear. Kidnapped at nineteen, Ma is a prisoner of a sadist called Old Nick. As adults we understand why Jack is put in the wardrobe each night when Old Nick gets home, where he waits counting the creaking of the springs until Old Nick leaves and he can come out once more. Because rations are scarce, everything is repurposed; toilet paper rolls become building blocks, a balloon is blown only once a month, the rug becomes a flying carpet. Their limited book collection is recited by heart, and no food is wasted. Ma, to protect Jack, has never told him that there is an outside world – the light from the skylight is God’s shining face and the people on TV are only on TV. Ma pulls from every resource around her to educate and nourish her son in this most bizarre setting.

As a reader you can see that Ma’s survival instincts are locked on high alert, but for Jack, except for the rare days when Ma is “gone,” it is mostly fun and games. Emma Donahue took a chance using Jack’s five year old voice to tell this story. Little boy talk could be a disaster but instead the reader is drawn to Jack’s untainted imagination and later, upon his release, to his naive, confused, or maybe not, first impressions of the “outside” world. The idea behind this mesmerizing novel and the way in which it is narrated are both exceptional. Donahue, this year’s runner up for the Man Booker prize, trusts the reader’s maturity to carry little Jack’s story forward.

Very clever Room is about the strength of a mother’s love and the notion that such a strong mother-son bond can be built regardless of circumstance. Despite everything, Jack’s Ma made him feel safe inside the room. Jack never really fully understands that for his Ma the room represents the place where her nightmare began, because for him it is home. It is Ma’s courage and unflinching love that makes her hell his sanctuary. Needless to say, this is an exceptional story.

Definitely worth five teacups!

(Five is the top Teacup score)

UJ READERS: Let Tanya know how many teacups out of five you give some of the books she recommends in this column – if we publish/or post on our website your 50-word (or less) comment, you will also get a FREE ‘GB sticker for your car’, how’s that? Email:


5 Responses to Books Review January 2011

  1. Ashley January 8, 2011 at 10:02 am

    How do you manage to make us want to read books about such tough subjects and situations? You really have a knack for it. One dose of Tanya-esque sunshine / enthusiasm / insight, / a quick synopsis and five tea cups and we are running to the bookstore. Sounds like a story written from a fascinating angle. Thanks for sharing!

  2. Larry Ureto January 8, 2011 at 12:10 pm

    Reminds me of Sartre, No exit.. except the devil was on the other side of the door, The Room, slowly unfolds in a similar manner. Great review Tanya

  3. Lindsay January 10, 2011 at 4:13 am

    Sounds interesting .. I’m not always sure children’s voices work either – didn’t Donna Tartt’s “Little Friend” use it very well, I think so. I wrote a short screenplay in the voice of a 13 year old coming of age. Its quite fascinating to put oneself in that frame of mind as an adult. I’ll read this after current read, Girl Who Kicked the Hornets Nest.

  4. Stephanie January 10, 2011 at 2:57 pm

    Tanya, I’m going online to the library right now and see if they have this book, sounds verrry interesting. Thanks for the heads up.

  5. Isabel August 25, 2012 at 9:33 am

    Started this book at 6am today, finished at 5pm. Shopping, lunch and three cups of tea were a distraction until I could turn the last page! An incredible read, one that will change my thinking for ever. As a Tiger Mother of 4 and Tiger Grandma of 5 little girls, the maternal spirit of ‘Ma’ to protect, care, cherish and love was ever present. Thank you Emma for your brave book.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The Union Jack has been published monthly since April 1982. Our readership now exceeds 220,000 throughout the USA. We serve a devoted readership comprised primarily of British expatriates, ranging from recent immigrants to war brides who relocated to the States a half-century ago, as well as a growing number of American Anglophiles. All of our readers, whether aged 25 or 75, share a common desire to maintain strong ties to Britain and the British community in America.

Union Jack’s regular advertisers include specialty shops and wholesalers, pubs, restaurants, immigration attorneys, insurance providers, financial services, shipping companies, travel agents and a variety of mail order gift suppliers, all of whom seek the unique and lucrative link Union Jack provides to one of the USA’s largest yet most assimilated ethnic markets. Our advertisers range from small ‘mom and pop’ business to larger businesses.

Circulation and Distribution

The Union Jack is a monthly tabloid newspaper, and is distributed throughout the United States via subscription and a variety of specially targeted distribution locations including British pubs, restaurants, specialty stores, as well as British government offices, consulates and business organizations such as the British American Chamber of Commerce and tourist offices.

All advertising inquiries should be directed to:

Union Jack Publishing
PO Box 1823, La Mesa, CA 91944-1823

or call us at:
(619) 466-3129

or Email us: